as i mentioned a couple of posts earlier, i’ve been on a bit of a quest to find apps which use the additional features i have on my iphone, as compared to the ipod touch. mostly this means i’m looking at apps which avail of compass, GPS and/or camera:
redlaser & pic2shop - barcode scanners


a bit of an change for you today. i’m going to review these two apps together and compare them. they’re both quite similar and do similar things, so there disnae seem much point writing two separate reviews. also, they’re both free so, if you’re interested you might as well grab both and see which you prefer.
redlaser & pic2shop both use the iphone’s camera to capture barcodes and identify products. so therefore they require a camera [duh!] and an intarwebs connection to search their databases and look up the items.
to use, you select the appropriate capture mode, which fires up the iphone’s camera. you then simply line up the barcode in on-screen sights and let the app get it in focus. with any luck you’ll then hear a beep -similar to the barcode readers in supermarkets- which tells you the barcode has been read. redlaser seems to acquire and read the barcodes quicker than pic2shop. both apps have difficulty reading barcodes on bottles or crumply/reflective materials. again redlaser seems to score slightly better.
FIRST PIC: redlaser - SECOND PIC: pic2shop - i’m having to hold redlaser off the barcode, as its acquisition time is so quick i couldnae get a screengrab before it went to the results screen. pic2shop takes a second or two longer, so i could screengrab in time:


BARCODE READING: redlaser
after the barcode has been read, both apps then search their database of items to try and match the barcode. here again, redlaser was the winner for me. whilst both apps do equally well with what you might call ‘global’ items; books, DVDs, electronic gadgets and the like, redlaser was far more successful at identifying ‘local’ items such as food packets and suchlike from my local supermarket. this is obviously a ‘YMMV’ situation - you’d have to test both apps in your own country and see which is best. one thing i did find tho’ was that pic2shop did throw up spurious results on more than one occasion, when confused by a smaller local item [it identified a bag of ASDA cheese’n’onion crisps as an HP laptop battery!], whereas redlaser either got it right or identified it more vaguely [but still correctly as] “product of ASDA stores ltd.” as regards database lookup times, i’ve only tested it over wifi, not ‘in the field’. both apps returned results instantly.
search results screen. FIRST PIC: redlaser, SECOND PIC: pic2shop. redlaser’s layout is a lot cleaner:


DATABASE RANGE: redlaser
SPEED OF RESULT RETURN: draw
i think that both apps must somehow allow you to submit your own info to their databases, as i hardly imagine the developers have the means to access barcode info for products around the world, but i’ve not been able to find a way to do this through either app. if either app cannae identifiy a barcode, they throw up a similar screen which provides options for searching via google or amazon for the item. i think both apps are glaringly missing a “submit item” button here.
UNKNOWN ITEM HANDLING: draw
item not found screen. FIRST PIC: redlaser, SECOND PIC: pic2shop. again, redlaser’s layout is a lot cleaner:


for those situations where either app is having problems reading the barcode, both will also allow you to manually enter the long number underneath and search manually. unfortunately your humble reviewer is to feckin’ lazy to be arsed testing this, but i’ll assume it works on both apps.
manual code entry. FIRST PIC: redlaser, SECOND PIC: pic2shop:


when a barcode has been correctly identified, both apps will return a small thumbnail of the item and a price comparison list showing the current price of that item at a variety of sites. in theory, you can then click through to order that item directly. this usually works well, although sometimes clicking through just results in a blank screen and spinning cursor. the blame for this may lie with the sites in question tho’, rather than the apps, as both seem to baulk at the same sites. i prefer redlaser’s interface for the results checking. it’s more neatly arranged and, after viewing a result, you can return to the results screen by clicking a iOS style back button. pic2shop superimposes two grey arrows on top of the results themselves, to navigate back and forth and –when viewing a retailer’s web page in the results– you have to make sure and position a clear bit of the page underneath the back arrow, otherwise any links underneath activate when you click on it.
the reason pic2shop have had to use this stupid navigation system is because their app is polluted with adverts, so in the space at the top of the screen, where redlaser uses a nice iOS style navbar, pic2shop sticks a feckin’ ad! :vomit:
results clickthrough. FIRST PIC: redlaser, SECOND PIC: pic2shop. once again redlaser’s layout is just so much cleaner and more logical:


redlaser also wins, when it comes to accessing previously scanned items; the main screen comprises a compact list of items you have scanned, which you can click through at any time [you can even favourite items and email them as a wishlist]. with pic2shop, previous results are available from the results screen by scrolling down the page. if the results for the item you have just scanned fill a full screen, as they do in these screenshots, it is not immediately apparent that there are more results underneath. in fact, for a long time i thought that pic2shop only remembered the last item scanned. after you’ve scanned about a dozen or so items, having to swipe down through that many screensful of results to find a previous item soon becomes a major PITA. redlaser’s list is a much cleaner and better implementation.
previous results. FIRST PIC: redlaser, SECOND PIC: pic2shop - redlaser’s previous results are always there, nicely listed and selectable on the main screen. pic2shop just keeps adding to the full results screen, so you have to scroll through the whole thing every time:


ACCESS PREVIOUS RESULTS: redlaser
so that’s about it. in my opinion, redlaser beats pic2shop in every department. ironically, when you fire up the apps, pic2shop looks the more professional as it displays some nice toolbar icons and [if you’ve used it before] a thumbnail of the last scanned item on the results page. redlaser just has a boring looking list and a ‘lightning bolt’ button. you’d be forgiven for thinking [as i did initially] that redlaser was going to be the lesser app. once you’ve used both for a while tho’, you realise the opposite is true. pic2shops’s home screen icons are about the only area were it beats redlaser.
for me tho’, the final nail in the coffin for pic2shop is that it uses adverts. i know they dinnae bother some people but i absolutely loathe advertising, both on TV and in applications. even if the apps were evenly matched, for that reason alone redlaser will be the one i keep and pic2shop will be going to the great app store in the sky.
NOT HAVING FECKING ADVERTS: redlaser
REDLASER
COST: free
RATING:
- one star off for not being able to add your own items
PIC2SHOP
COST: free
RATING:
- not as accurate. and let down by poorly designed interface and adverts